Commentary
That it may come to them, a part of the hour, like: that it may tread upon them, from His saying: "Men who believe and women who believe." And it was read: that it may come to them, with a pause on the hour and a resumption of the condition. And it is in the Mushafs of the people of Mecca likewise. If you say: What is the reward of the condition? I say: His saying: "So how will it be for them?" Its meaning is: If the hour comes to them, how will their remembrance be for them, meaning their remembering and being admonished when the hour comes to them? It means that remembrance will not benefit them then, like His saying: "On that Day, man will remember, and how will his remembrance benefit him?" If you say: What does His saying: "Indeed, the signs of it have come" connect to in both readings? I say: To the coming of the hour, the connection of the cause with the effect, like saying: If Zayd honors me, then I am deserving of honor, I will honor him. And the signs are the indicators. Abu al-Aswad said:
"If you have indeed resolved to cut off between us... Then you have made the signs of its beginning appear."
(Abu al-Aswad is saying: If you have determined to sever the bond between us, do not hide it, for the signs of its beginning have begun to appear.)
And it was said: The sending of Muhammad, the Seal of the Prophets, blessings and peace be upon him, and the splitting of the moon, and the smoke.
And from al-Kalbi: The abundance of wealth and trade, bearing false witness, severing ties of kinship, few honorable people, and the prevalence of veils. And it was read: suddenly, with the weight of jarba. It is strange and has not been mentioned in the sources of its sister, and it is narrated from Abu Amr. And I fear that it may be a mistake from the narrator on Abu Amr, and that the correct reading is: suddenly, with the opening of the ghain without emphasis, like the reading of al-Hasan as previously mentioned.
Explore Other Scholars on This Verse
Compare different scholarly perspectives on Surah Muhammad verse 18