Commentary
It was recited, 'I have gone astray' [Aḍallu] with the opening of the 'ayn along with its kasrah. And 'I have gone astray' [Aḍallu] with its kasrah along with the opening. Both are two dialects, similar to: 'I have remained' [Ẓallaltu] and 'I have remained' [Ẓallaltu]. And it was recited 'Aḍallu' with the kasrah of the hamzah along with the opening of the 'ayn. If you say: Where is the contrast between His saying, 'For indeed, I only lead astray myself' [Fa innama Aḍillu 'ala Nafsi] and His saying, 'And it is by what my Lord inspires me' [Wa bima Yūḥī Ilayya Rabbī]? It would be more appropriate to say: 'For indeed, I lead astray myself, and if I am guided, then I am guided for it,' like His saying, 'Whoever does good, it is for himself, and whoever does evil, it is against it' [Man 'Amila Ṣāliḥan Fa Lin-Nafsi Wa Man 'Asā'a Fa 'Alayhā]. So whoever is guided, it is for himself, and whoever goes astray, he only leads himself astray. Or it can be said: 'For indeed, I lead astray by myself.' I say: They are contrasted in terms of meaning, because the self is all that is upon it, meaning: that all that is a burden upon it and harmful to it is by it and because of it; because the commanding self to evil, and what benefits it is by the guidance of its Lord and His success. This is a general ruling for every accountable person. And it was only commanded to His Messenger [sallallahu alayhi wasallam] to attribute it to himself, because when the Messenger is included with the greatness of his burden and the correctness of his path, others are more deserving of it. Indeed, He is All-Hearing, Near, perceiving the words of every misguided and guided one, and His actions are not hidden from Him, whether one of them.
Explore Other Scholars on This Verse
Compare different scholarly perspectives on Surah Saba verse 50