Commentary
One of them is Judah, and he was the best among them in opinion. He is the one who said, 'I will not leave the land.' He said to them: 'Killing is a great matter; throw him into the depths of the pit,' which is its bottom and what is hidden from the eye of the observer and darker than its lower part. Al-Mankhal said: 'And if one day my grave hides me, then walk in my way among the tribe and the family.' [This is attributed to Al-Mankhal. The ghayabah is what is hidden from the observer from the bottom of the well and the like. He says: 'If my grave hides me,' a metaphor for his death, 'then walk in my way,' meaning mourn me and walk with the mention of my qualities, as is the custom of the Arabs when a leader among them dies. It is possible that he is advising his relatives to do good, and that they walk in a manner similar to his, and act as he did towards his neighbors and relatives.] He meant the ghayabah of the pit in which he is buried. It has been read as ghayabat, in the plural. And ghayabat, with emphasis. Al-Jahdari read: ghaybah. And al-jubb is the well that has not been covered, because the earth digs a jubb and nothing else. It is picked up by some travelers among the people who are walking on the road. And it has been read: 'tulqituhu,' with the ta, according to the meaning, because some of the travelers are a caravan, as in the saying: 'As the breast of the spear was drenched with blood.' [This witness has been explained in the first part, page 395, refer to it if you wish, O corrector.] And from it: 'Some of his fingers went away.' 'If you are able to do what will achieve your aim, this is the opinion.'
Explore Other Scholars on This Verse
Compare different scholarly perspectives on Surah Yusuf verse 10